Canadian policymakers prioritizing wrong segment in red-hot housing—economist

by Ephraim Vecina10 Jun 2016
By solely aiming to resolve demand-side issues, Canadian authorities are missing the big picture when it comes to addressing the country’s overheated housing markets, according to a prominent economist.
 
In a report by BNN's John Gray, Gluskin Sheff + Associates chief economist and strategist David Rosenberg argued that the strategies currently proposed by various quarters—which include “tinkering” via CMHC guidelines or continuously adjusting down payment requirements—are woefully inadequate as they are neglecting an important segment.
 
“We continue to focus on the wrong area,” Rosenberg said in his interview with BNN. “The focus [needs to be on the] supply constraints that politicians at every level of government can ease up.”
 
“Where is the emphasis on zoning regulations, on making incentives to increase building approvals, on making it easier for the builders to respond to this strong demand?” the analyst added.
 
Furthermore, federal intervention such as added taxes on foreign nationals would not work in cooling down Canada’s real estate markets as these buyers are “inherently non-price sensitive”, Rosenberg said.
 
“What’s the federal government going to do that it hasn’t done? [And] the Bank of Canada isn’t going to raise interest rates in this environment,” the economist said.
 
A more pressing problem is looming just beyond the horizon, however, as the affordability crisis is quickly shaping up to be not just a financial consideration, but also a social risk considering that millennials are among the buying populations most affected by the seemingly non-stop price growth.
 
“What you are doing is pricing an entire generation of young people out of the real estate market,” Rosenberg warned.
 

COMMENTS

  • by Joan McGuigan 6/10/2016 10:53:30 AM

    Not in Montreal! This market needs a boost not boot straps! 80% of real estate agents here cannot make a decent living. You describe the Canadian real estate market by Toronto and Vancouver prices. Shame on you. Quebec real estate has been woefully low for years. Why not let the ROC know this and maybe spread the word that there are great buys in Montreal besides being a fantastic place to live. Let's hear more about La Belle Province for a change!

  • by Mike 6/10/2016 1:03:12 PM

    I've always wondered why CMHC doesn't set lending policies on a more regional basis like the Federal government does with unemployment Insurance???

  • by Jim 6/22/2016 8:49:52 AM

    Because, as I understand it CMHC does mortgage insurance, not lending. Banks lend.

Poll

Is a Toronto foreign sales tax a good idea?